Pete, Claudia, and Myka are called in to help Fargo, who is trapped in a virtual reality swords & sorcery game. Meanwhile, Artie and Steve are summoned to New York to recover an artifact... by FBI agent Sally Stukowski.

In the aftermath of the warehouse's destruction, the Warehouse team races against the clock to find a way to undo time itself and put right what went wrong. However, Artie finds himself facing a difficult decision when he is warned that saving the warehouse will unleash an even greater evil.

While Pete and Myka go to Toronto to investigate an invulnerable hockey player, Steve helps Artie track down stolen artifacts while Claudia meets with Mrs. Fredericks to discuss her future as a warehouse guardian.