The Division investigates the murder of Sara Allen who was looking for her daughter. At the scene a note was found telling Sarah's daughter that she was a bad mom but was still looking for her daughter. Magda meets "" a floating inspector "" named Regan (who is filling in for Jinny who is on maternity leave)

Magda doesn't like Regan and soon learns that the inspector has a lot of questions to answer. As Magda and Regan look into the murder of Sara Allen Regan is looking at footage of a news report and soon sees a suspect on screen.

Kate asks Magda to go undercover at a foster care agency to look for the daughter of Sara Allen only to discover that several children are missing. Reagan does some investigating of her own while serving as a guard for Magda. She carries with her a picture of David (the person she saw on the news report)

Kate learns that a coma victim has awakened after nine years. Kate hopes to solve the case with the help of the victim. Also Regan learns that her son David was accused of stalking someone and is also schizophrenic. Now Reagan asks Kate if she can look at the files.

Stacey Reynolds tries to help Emma Weber to reconnect with her family she is worried that her son won't remember her after nine years. Emma identifies the person who killed her husband Evan nine years ago from a picture in the newspaper.

Reagan continues to find evidence to prove her son's innocence. When Reagan and Kate try to interview him in prison they don't get much information out of David as to whether he killed Mary O' Reilly. Stacey is asked to help her friend track down his missing sisters. Stacey learns that the missing sisters came from Chechnya .

After the sisters of Stacey's friend are located in a truck inside the truck four bodies are found dead due to dehydration. Stacey 's friend is asked to see if he is sister Katrina is one of the bodies in the truck. Miquel tells Magda that Katrina is still missing.

Reagan goes to visit David who questions whether he killed Mary and wonders what might happen if he is convicted of the murder.