Jess and Nicole are called in to help when a hurricane breaches destruction on a small North Carolinian town and dozens of people go missing. Jess' visions lead them to a young boy but shockingly, he's kidnapped from the hospital. The team works hard to find him, concentrating especially on his single father, whose wife (the mother of the missing boy) left him and their son two years earlier. Jess is attracted to a man who she caught attempting to break into the father's car. Pollack scolds Janey for a judgement call she was forced to make.

A mother and her young children witness a middle-aged woman being kidnapped in a parking lot. Jess has a vision while trying to corner a suspect that nearly lets him get away. The agents discover that the woman was trying to be as anonymous and invisible as possible and they learn a horrifying secret that hits too close to home for Nicole, who reveals a deadly secret about her childhood. Meanwhile, Antonio encourages Nicole to share what's bothering her and Jess is asked out by Colin, the undercover agent she worked with in "Unnatural Disaster".

The agents search for a wealthy businessman who disappeared from his hotel. They try to get the truth out of his girlfriend, who discovered him missing in the middle of the night. When Pollack's team is ordered off the case by his boss, he risks his job to continue working on it. Meanwhile, Pollack tries to reconcile with his wife.

The agents search for a young boy who goes missing while his grandmother babysits him. Their investigation leads them to his family, who have hired an aggressive lawyer. The shocking results of the grandmother's polygraph test leads to an even more surprising conclusion. In the end, the agents face off with a psycho and must outwit him to find the boy alive. Meanwhile, Jess tells Colin that she's psychic and is disappointed by his reaction while Nicole and Antonio worry that Pollack will transfer one of them now that they suspect he knows that they're in a relationship.

Nicole gets to know her mom and tries to get to know her better. They also try to find a missing Department of Justice agent and try to find out why and who blew the cover of the DOJ agent.