In the beginning, a plague crossed over the House of Heidelbaum. Its youngest, Jonah, was plunged into the belly of the whale; but was culled from the darkness by the shepherd Meyer Offerman. Somewhere across the ancient land of Manhattan, Millie Morris, a guardian of the law, whose faith hath been tested, trekked South upon the death of an elderly woman.

After discovering a clue about a murderous foe, Jonah travels to a wondrous land to locate a great evil and avenge his family. But his search lands Jonah in mortal peril that only the great shepherd Meyer Offerman can rescue him from. Meanwhile, down in the land of Florida, Millie Morris discovers that evil has many faces and that her search for truth may reveal more than she bargained for.

Марри и Минди обнаруживают шифр в радиосообщениях Карла, в котором говорится, что некоторые трагические события прошлого США были частью нацистского заговора. В сообщениях говорится, что следующая крупная нацистская диверсия запланирована на 13 июля 1977 года, а местом проведения выбран Нью-Йорк. Друг Джоны, подменявший последнего на работе, был убит Трэвисом.

«Охотники» обнаруживают хранилище еврейских ценностей, отнятых у евреев нацистами во время войны. Хранилище находится в банке в Нью-Джерси. Джона находит записи Руфь, в которых описывается развитие её отношений с Мейером в концентрационном лагере Освенцим.

В концентрационном лагере Освенцим доктор по кличке Волк предлагает Руфь работать с ним, но она отказывается, в отместку он начинает мучить Мейера. Половина «Охотников» отправляется в Алабаму, чтобы найти нацистского доктора, который экспериментировал над заключенными во время войны, в то время, как другая часть группы находит Тильду Сауэр, нацистского пропагандистского кинорежиссера. Милли продолжает вести своё расследование о присутствии нацистов в Америке. Сестра Харриет находит высокопоставленного нациста и уезжает вместе с ним.

В день свадьбы своей дочери Мюррей вспоминает, как его с женой и маленьким сыном отправили в концентрационный лагерь, где офицер убил их сына. Демонстрируются воспоминания сестры Харриет, оказывается, что она была тайно переправлена в Английский монастырь с другими молодыми девушками, чтобы спрятаться на время войны.

Hark! A wedding song rang out to unite The Hunters in a time of discord. “The Hunt is not only about death,” Meyer cried unto Jonah, “It is about life!” But their mirth was tempered by an untimely strike and suspicions of a Judas among them. Seeking the origins of Evil, Millie offered up a sacrifice.

And there was a thick darkness in all the land. As The Hunters wallowed in the valley of the shadow of death, they turned to the stars to point them on their path. Still, darkness trespassed up on the heart of Jonah, which did tempt him toward sin; and the shepherd Meyer petitioned Millie to join their flock.

As a terrible plague loomed over the land and did portend to devour its people, The Hunters waged a great battle to prevent it. Upon the threshold of righteousness, Millie endured a loathsome betrayal and sought to deliver Jonah from vengeance and corruption.

Харриет спасает Мейера. «Охотники» считают, что «Полковник» мертва. Джона начинает поиски «Волка», нацистского врача, который пытал Мейера и Руфь тридцать лет назад. Из записей бабушки Джона находит файлы, которые помогают ему вычислить местонахождение хирурга, которого он считает тем самым «Волком».

Two years after a failed mission scattered The Hunters, Jonah is living a double life in Paris with his fiancée, Clara. Soon, he discovers the most notorious Nazi in history may still be alive. Meanwhile, in Los Angeles, Millie Morris prosecutes a dangerous war criminal. And years before the founding of The Hunters, Meyer Offerman encounters a dangerous threat that could expose his true identity.

Jonah convinces Millie to join him on the hunt for Hitler and the duo brings The Hunters back together for one last mission – their most important hunt of all. After The Hunters land in South America, they are soon imperiled by a dangerous foe. In New York City, Meyer Offerman gets closer to unearthing the whereabouts of a former Nazi who threatens to destroy him.

Jonah, Millie, and The Hunters reluctantly agree to join forces with Chava after discovering her true identity and her connection to Jonah. The team heads to a luxury hotel in the Argentinian countryside to intercept the one person who knows of Hitler’s whereabouts – a famed Nazi assassin known only as “The Crow.” Meanwhile, Meyer collides with the old Nazi colleague who is blackmailing him.

As our Hunters grow closer to discovering Hitler’s location, Jonah's secret life is jeopardized when his fiancée Clara shows up in Argentina. Meanwhile, Travis and a brainwashed Joe pursue The Hunters in a plot to kill them once and for all. In the past, Meyer and Ruth's connection is revealed and we discover the origins of The Hunters.

Reeling from the events at the Hotel Palladio, Jonah leads a team to rescue the love of his life before it’s too late. Meanwhile, one of our Hunters fights for their life. In the past, as Meyer heads to Germany to recruit a new member of The Hunters, Ruth begins to grow suspicious of Meyer.

In an expansive Argentinian valley, our Hunters discover Hitler’s compound and find themselves in the presence of ultimate evil, as a cataclysmic battle between good and evil ignites. In the past, we learn that Meyer and Chava have met before, a truth Meyer kept from Ruth for so many years, all as Ruth’s suspicions about Meyer’s true identity escalate.

As Jonah attempts to smuggle the greatest evil out of Argentina to meet justice, we travel back in time to war-torn Germany to the home of a peculiar old couple whose story has reverberations for Jonah’s success or failure.

Adolf Hitler finally faces justice on the world stage, as the trial of the century begins. Jonah tries to salvage the life he once had with Clara. Finally, we discover the horrific conclusion of Ruth’s pursuit of Meyer’s true identity. As the past, present, and future collide, Jonah, Meyer, Millie and our Hunters are left wondering whether the hunt for evil can ever truly end.