Would you prefer it was an "ordinary" Western?

Discuter de Mannen med oxpiskan

Discuter → Films → Mannen med oxpiskan → Générales

posté par Strawberry Shortcake
STAFFMOD
le 21 juin 2017 à 07h29

After reading all the fiery discussions about this film in IMDB, I thought how easy it could have been to make this film an ordinary Western, by omitting the controversial scenes and the dark secrets: a stranger comes to a town which some mean bullies terrorize simply because they can; the local sheriff is a coward; the stranger learns about the situation and decides, of altruism, to stay and help the town people to defend themselves, and in the meantime starts a romance with a nice local woman. In the end, the bad guys are either killed or imprisoned and the decent people live happily ever after.

Would you pefer the movie to be that way?

10 réponses (sur la page 1 sur 1)

• Jump to last post

Réponse de John Ell

STAFFMOD

le 21 juin 2017 à 09h14

No.

Réponse de Joe79

STAFFMOD

le 21 juin 2017 à 11h22

@John Ell said:

No.

^{^} This

Réponse de bluersun

STAFFMOD

le 21 juin 2017 à 15h09

@Joe79 said:

@John Ell said:

No.

^{^} This

^ And that

Réponse de tmdb82469342

STAFFMOD

le 2 novembre 2020 à 13h40

@bluersun said:

@Joe79 said:

@John Ell said:

No.

^{^} This

^ And that

^ That too!

Réponse de bluersun

STAFFMOD

le 18 novembre 2020 à 20h06

@GusGorman said:

@bluersun said:

@Joe79 said:

@John Ell said:

No.

^{^} This

^ And that

^ That too!

And the other... Oh wait...

Réponse de sukhisoo

STAFFMOD

le 18 septembre 2021 à 10h51

There are no good guys. Except maybe the dwarf.

Dark movie that is worth a rewatch or five.

Réponse de tmdb53400018

STAFFMOD

le 18 septembre 2021 à 11h21

@sukhisoo said:

There are no good guys. Except maybe the dwarf.

Dark movie that is worth a rewatch or five.

I agree. The metaphysical stuff makes the film more fun too.

Réponse de sukhisoo

STAFFMOD

le 18 septembre 2021 à 19h35

@CelluloidFan said:

@sukhisoo said:

There are no good guys. Except maybe the dwarf.

Dark movie that is worth a rewatch or five.

I agree. The metaphysical stuff makes the film more fun too.

I like that it stayed ambiguous as to whether our drifter was an avenging angel of death or just as gunfighter

Réponse de DonGable

STAFFMOD

le 25 janvier 2023 à 15h56

It got better as it went on. At first, it seemed like it would be a run-of-the-mill film, but I like how it turned around. Clint is so freaking cool! :D

Réponse de Tresix

STAFFMOD

le 4 septembre 2023 à 12h57

Was the rape necessary?

Membres de cette conversation

Catégories

Discuter de Mannen med oxpiskan