American Sniperについてのディスカッション

5 replies (on page 1 of 1)

Jump to last post

I have always espoused the phrase, 'One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter'.

I haven't read the article yet, I'll read it later tonight or tomorrow.

Answer: director = Clint Eastwood what do I win???

@DRDMovieMusings said:

Here's an even more scathing review - Every movie rewrites history. What American Sniper did is much, much worse.

Ouch. Well we can only hope, as with all propaganda films, that history won’t remember it kindly. Probably not though. People still adore Zero Dark Thirty even though it’s just a paper thinly veiled rally cry to justify the CIA’s torture of war prisoners (which ironically in the film, as well as reality, didn’t even yield any useful information). My guess is there’s always a violent fringe audience who wants to see dumbed-down “good guy vs bad guy” war flicks where their side is the good guy. And directors like Eastwood are only too ready to sell it. I lost all respect for the guy when he endorsed Trump. But at least he’s kinda shut his mouth about politics ever since his team trashed the Capitol building. I just hope he isn’t working on a film about those “patriots”.

@rooprect said:

@DRDMovieMusings said:

Here's an even more scathing review - Every movie rewrites history. What American Sniper did is much, much worse.

My guess is there’s always a violent fringe audience who wants to see dumbed-down “good guy vs bad guy” war flicks where their side is the good guy. And directors like Eastwood are only too ready to sell it.

Yep. This movie paid a handsome $9.22 of revenue for each production budget dollar.

I lost all respect for the guy when he endorsed Trump. But at least he’s kinda shut his mouth about politics ever since his team trashed the Capitol building. I just hope he isn’t working on a film about those “patriots”.

We can only hope.

One of the points from these critiques that carries a lot of weight for me is the contention that producers of these movies are not even honest with the available information. So determined are they to tell/sell their fabrication to their base, facts be damned - instead of adding constructively to public discourse, they seem to prefer to cash in while fomenting and fanning flames of division.

I'd say "shame on him" but this mindset seems incapable of shame.

映画やテレビ番組が見つかりませんか?ログインして作成してください。

全般

s 検索バーに移動する
p プロファイルメニューを開く
esc 開いているウィンドウを閉じる
? キーボードショートカットウィンドウを開く

メディアのページ

b 戻る(または該当する場合は親に)
e 編集ページに行く

テレビ番組のシーズンのページ

(右矢印)次のシーズンに行く
(左矢印)前のシーズンに戻る

テレビ番組のエピソードのページ

(右矢印)次のエピソードに進む
(左矢印)前のエピソードに戻る

全ての画像のページ

a 画像追加ウィンドウを開く

全ての編集ページ

t 翻訳選択を開く
ctrl+ s フォームを送信する

ディスカッションのページ

n 新しいディスカッションを作成する
w 監視ステータスを切り替える
p 公開/非公開を切り替える
c 閉じる/開くを切り替える
a アクティビティを開く
r ディスカッションに返信
l 最後の返事に行く
ctrl+ enter メッセージを送信する
(右矢印)次のページ
(左矢印)前のページ

設定

このアイテムを評価したり、リストに追加したりしたいですか?

ログイン

メンバーではありませんか?

登録してコミュニティに参加