Bespreek Phoenix

Virtually the entire tale is ludicrous. As soon as the main plot thread appeared I wanted to detest this film for the absurd coincidence, pathetic interpretation of facial reconstruction and for exploiting an infamous suffering for he sake of a yarn.

Yet when the credits rolled, I'd forgiven it almost completely. An absurd but powerful ending.

Could anyone else forgive the film it's failings? Could anyone forgive Johnny?

6/10

2 antwoorde (op blad 1 van 1)

Jump to last post

They never made it clear if he had really betrayed her - but I believe he did, so no , I wouldn't forgive Johnny. I found her attempt to make up a scenario whereby he was innocent absolutely pathetic. I can't understand why he could claim the estate of a wife he had divorced. What made him think she needed to give him anything let alone the lions share. That whole scenario was so badly thought out by the writers - it was just silly. I think they should have expanded on her relationship with Lene who was obviously gay - but Nelly obviously wasn't so that was a bit of a puzzle. I don't think the ending was powerful - maybe it was to illustrate the point that Lene made about victims forgiving their abusers - I was fully expecting her to hug him at the station and shoot him at the same time - that would have been more satisfying to me !!!

The main plot is ludicrous and you have to switch your suspension-of-disbelief mode to "full" to be able to follow (one does not recognise a partner just by the face... what about the hands, the gait, the body language, the smell, etc.)... but once you've done that, amazingly, it works. The atmosphere is well recreated, the trauma of a society where victims and killers coexist smiling in the same old picture. I also found the end compelling, although the death of Lene need to be explained a little more.

Kan ’n rolprent of TV-program nie vind nie? Teken aan om dit te skep.

Globaal

s fokus op soekbalk
p open profielkieslys
esc sluit ’n oop venster
? open sneltoetsvenster

Op mediablaaie

b gaan terug (na ouer waar van toepassing)
e gaan na wysigblad

Op TV-seisoenblaaie

(regterpyl) gaan na volgende seisoen
(linkerpyl) gaan na vorige seisoen

Op TV-episodeblaaie

(regterpyl) gaan na volgende episode
(linkerpyl) gaan na vorige episode

Op alle beeldblaaie

a open beeldtoevoegvenster

Op alle wysigingsblaaie

t open vertaalkieser
ctrl+ s dien form in

Op besprekingsblaaie

n skep nuwe bespreking
w tokkel kykstatus
p tokkel openbaar/privaat
c tokkel maak oop/toe
a open aktiwiteit
r reageer op bespreking
l gaan na laaste reaksie
ctrl+ enter dien u boodskap in
(regterpyl) volgende blad
(linkerpyl) vorige blad

Instellings

Wil u hierdie item gradeer of tot ’n lys toevoeg?

Teken aan