A sequel, I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer was originally meant to star survivors Jennifer Love Hewitt, Brandy Norwood and Freddie Prinze Jr. again. However, the film was left alone for a while and the original script, which involved Jennifer, Brandy and Freddie, was scrapped and a whole new script was written.

I wish we could've seen this film. The one they made was terrible and would've felt like a real conclusion to the trilogy