The lead had a certain charisma to carry off the role and obviously it deserves plaudits as kickstarting an entire genre, but overall, 90 years later, this is perhaps one to watch as a fan of film, rather than as a bit of standalone entertainment.
The acting is variable, the humour is leaden and, well, I've never seen a woman try to seduce a man by tap dancing for him!
The bizarre text intro inciting voters to elect officials to crack down on gangsters was clearly just an attempt to get a film glamourising thugs past the censors.
6/10 (same as I gave the '83 remake)
Не можете найти фильм или сериал? Войдите на сайт, чтобы добавить его.
Хотите поставить оценку или добавить в список?
Нет аккаунта?
Ответ от tmdb53400018
, 17 марта 2022 в 22:54
I would say Brian DePalma's remake is 'of this time,' because it is so loved. Since the corrupt, incestuous murderer played by Al Pacino keeps winning over admirers from generation after generation, the film must belong to the 'times' -- or even possibly be timeless.
I feel DePalma's film is becoming just as much an artifact for fans of film as the original one is.
Ответ от bratface
, 17 марта 2022 в 23:56
Does anybody know what 'mech' did to get banned?
Ответ от tmdb53400018
, 18 марта 2022 в 00:07
"Banned?"
I tried to tell him that the language making light of the Holocaust was in poor taste and offensive.
Ответ от tmdb53400018
, 18 марта 2022 в 11:16
The film is so unbelievably gaudy to watch now, though. I mean, Tony's suits... the mountain of coke on his desk... wow.
Ответ от JustinJackFlash
, 18 марта 2022 в 11:33
The big problem is that he posted so many messages that now that they're all gone the rest of us are going to look like we've all been talking to ourselves. We'll look crazy, lol.
Ответ от Fergoose
, 20 марта 2022 в 18:22
Yeah. I don't think much of the remake, but being over the top with violence and language it's still very current and likely to engage a certain type of modern viewer. With the original I can imagine it being captivating at the time but now it's like something from another planet.
Ответ от wonder2wonder
, 20 марта 2022 в 19:10
• The art of tap dancing
Ответ от tmdb53400018
, 20 марта 2022 в 22:24
I viewed Hawks' film years back and don't recall a ton about it. I remember feeling it's a good film--not as memorable as the 1983 remake with all of the garish excess and extreme graphic violence. I seem to remember Hawks' film having a nice, suspenseful last act... always a good thing.