Horimiya 토론

Item: Horimiya

Language: en-US

Type of Problem: Incorrect_content

Extra Details: Horimiya: Piece is being considered as a Side Story. Should it be added as a 2nd Season or a Separate Show?

Proof: https://myanimelist.net/anime/42897 (Check Related Anime Section)

I'm asking this before more data gets added and mods decides to do otherwise.

10 댓글 (1 / 1)

Jump to last post

Not really sure how to decide here. From what I've read, the original anime adapted the manga fully, but left out a lot of chapters that will be adapted in Horimiya: Piece. So it might make more sense for it to be added as a completely new series than a season 2.

Normally, side stories, as opposed to sequels, should be listed as a separate entry.

But, here, like @Sheigutn , I have a problem. It is listed as a side-story on MyAnimeList and AnimeNewsNetwork, but as a sequel on AniDB.

So, I will let @Sheigutn decide.

@Temp8799 said:

Here we go, it started happening.

https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/110070/season/2

https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/223174

I've noticed it too. Only after I reported it as duplicate. Let me know what will be decided. Still maybe cause it's officially restarted and will continue in season 2, which few believed, for me takes logic to stick as season 2 here and not separate 😌

@Sheigutn said:

Not really sure how to decide here. From what I've read, the original anime adapted the manga fully, but left out a lot of chapters that will be adapted in Horimiya: Piece. So it might make more sense for it to be added as a completely new series than a season 2.

I agree with you. Since most of the other databases are considering it as a Side Story it's better to keep it as a separate show to keep the data consistent.

Also, if you consider going with a separate show please lock the create new season button of this one.

Ok, just to be sure. The separated show was deleted, so this will be listed as season 2 of the main show?

Personally, I believe it should be separeated, just like Ousama Ranking this season. I just wanted to know if this decision is definitive.

I forgot about this thread, but I'd still stick to my original opinion that separating it would be better. Seems like in the meantime Rebecca deleted the other entry because of Jagx's report and had no idea this discussion here existed.

I recreated it, removed season 2 here and locked the status.

@ParticularSecret10 said:

@Temp8799 said:

Here we go, it started happening.

https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/110070/season/2

https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/223174

I've noticed it too. Only after I reported it as duplicate. Let me know what will be decided. Still maybe cause it's officially restarted and will continue in season 2, which few believed, for me takes logic to stick as season 2 here and not separate 😌

I agree with you.It need be added season 2 !

It is season 2 on netflix .

찾으시는 영화나 TV 프로그램이 없나요? 로그인 하셔서 직접 만들어주세요.

전체

s 검색 바 띄우기
p 프로필 메뉴 열기
esc 열린 창 닫기
? 키보드 단축키 창 열기

미디어 페이지

b 돌아가기
e 편집 페이지로 이동

TV 시즌 페이지

(우 화살표) 다음 시즌으로 가기
(좌 화살표) 이전 시즌으로 가기

TV 에피소드 페이지

(우 화살표) 다음 에피소드로 가기
(좌 화살표) 이전 에피소드로 가기

모든 이미지 페이지

a 이미지 추가 창 열기

모든 편집 페이지

t 번역 선택 열기
ctrl+ s 항목 저장

토론 페이지

n 새 토론 만들기
w 보기 상태
p 공개/비공개 전환
c 열기/닫기 전환
a 활동 열기
r 댓글에 글쓰기
l 마지막 댓글로 가기
ctrl+ enter 회원님의 메세지 제출
(우 화살표) 다음 페이지
(좌 화살표) 이전 페이지

설정

Want to rate or add this item to a list?

로그인